FINE WINE STORAGE LAWSUITS: MANHATTAN’S WINECARE STORAGE SUED FOR BARRING CLIENTS ACCESS TO ITS 27,000 WINE CASES AFTER HURRICANE SANDY, OWNER DEREK LIMBOCKER CLAIMS WINES REMAIN UNDAMAGED

 More than 27,000 cases of fine wine worth tens of millions of dollars have been locked inside WineCare Storage, located in the Chelsea neighborhood, since Hurricane Sandy swept through the northeast

Manhattan‘s million-dollar mystery: How 27,000 cases of vintage wine ‘disappeared’ after Hurricane Sandy

By Daily Mail Reporter PUBLISHED: 22 July 2013

More than 27,000 cases of fine wine worth tens of millions of dollars have been locked inside WineCare Storage, located in the Chelsea neighborhood, since Hurricane Sandy swept through the Northeast and flooded the facility in late October.

Derek Limbocker, the owner of the warehouse – which is one of the largest wine care facilities in the country – claims 95 percent of the wines were undamaged in the storm.

 
More than 27,000 cases of fine wine worth tens of millions of dollars have been locked inside WineCare Storage, located in the Chelsea neighborhood, since Hurricane Sandy swept through the northeast More than 27,000 cases of fine wine worth tens of millions of dollars have been locked inside WineCare Storage, located in the Chelsea neighborhood, since Hurricane Sandy swept through the Northeast

 

 
This picture shows the inside of the climate-controlled facility, which was flooded by Sandy This picture shows the inside of the climate-controlled facility, which was flooded by Sandy

 

But he won’t let anyone inside his facility to assess the damage, and he won’t allow any of the wines to leave – even though customers are still being billed for the storage of their collections. Before the storm, WineCare used to offer its customers same-day delivery service for even a single bottle of wine.

A whole host of wealthy wine enthusiasts have filed suit against Limbocker to access their collections, but their high-priced lawyers have had little success.

By filing for bankruptcy, Limbocker has managed to sidestep every legal maneuver thrown at him – even a court-ordered injunction to allow one customer to view his 198 cases of wine, the New York Times reported.

 Limbocker filed for bankruptcy one day before Philip Waterman III, a real estate investor, was scheduled to inspect his $300,000 of wine stored at the facility.

Waterman and others are convinced that the wine stored inside the facility, which is set 100 yards back from the Hudson River, has been largely damaged or spoiled as a result of the storm and that’s why they haven’t been allowed to access it.

 Since the storm, no customers have been allowed in the facility and no wines have been allowed out

Since the storm, no customers have been allowed in the facility and no wines have been allowed out

 

A whole host of wealthy wine enthusiasts have filed suit against Limbocker to access their collections, but their high-priced lawyers have had little successA whole host of wealthy wine enthusiasts have filed suit against Limbocker to access their collections, but their high-priced lawyers have had little success

But lawyers for Limbocker claim his company is working to carefully clean the bottles and that stopping to scan the cases for their owners will unnecessarily prolong that process.

Limbocker has already revealed that humidity levels from the storm lifted the labels off of many cases and that cardboard boxes holding the wine disintegrated. He also reported that when cases were moved to avoid flood waters, thousands of bottles broke in transit.

Others taking legal action against WineCare include William C. Carmody, a trial lawyer with a $104,000 collection in storage and Keith McNally, whose restaurants – Minetta Tavern and Morandi – have filed claims for $2 million worth of wine and $1 million in damages, according to the Times.

Despite the lawsuits, Limbocker has been given the green light on a plan to relocate the wine to a warehouse in New Jersey, where the legal battles will surely continue.

 

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2374672/Manhattans-million-dollar-mystery-How-27-000-cases-vintage-wine-disappeared-Hurricane-Sandy.html#ixzz2ZqYfREX2
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s